Wednesday, October 16, 2019

Jim Rutt discussion with Bonnitta Roy

The transcript is here. I appreciated the discussion of soil experiments in different environments, that each niche has its own requirements, that there is no one soil solution for all of them.

This though extends to our modeling, in that when we draw a boundary something gets left out. Hence there is no one model that covers all the bases. It behooves us to do meta-analyses of which models fit best under which conditions, how each fills in some the gaps of the others.

Which of course relates to the discussion about boundaries, how they are semi-permeable, allowing for both an cohesive entity yet how it communicates and shares with its environment and other entities. Investigating those spaces between is a study in itself.

One question I have though is when Bonnie talks about the whole and no boundary, the entire developmental field. How could we possibly ever know (or feel, whatever) such a whole? The very notion of a field implies it too has boundaries. The discussion of the computronium made it clear that we cannot fathom its entirety, that we have to limit our knowledge to models that focus on bits and pieces.

Which of course related to the discussion of the universe, noting there were a multitude of them, each with their own laws of physics, etc. Again, fields with boundaries that perhaps we can come to know at least some of its attributes and laws. But what of those semi-permeable boundaries, those spaces between universes, do they interact?
It does make for interesting sci-fi, but what about the science of that?

In line with my comments above I'm reminded of Bruce Alderman's paper on generative enclosures in Integral Review. And as to the generative space between that allows a meta-analysis/synthesis of models, see this Edwards et al piece. 

The truth about their brazen lies

As if being brazen somehow makes them true. It doesn't.


Tuesday, October 15, 2019

Speaking about a transformation

Sanders wants to give workers an ownership stake in big companies.

"Sen. Bernie Sanders on Monday introduced a series of proposals designed to radically realign the balance of power in the American economy. The Vermont independent's agenda would guarantee workers eventually take control, through the issuance of new stock, of 20% stakes in the country's largest companies, while mandating that employees elect 45% of corporate boards of directors. The Sanders plan would also impose strict new guidelines on mega-mergers, while asking a revamped Federal Trade Commission to review deals pushed through during the Trump administration."

Sanders on a difference with Warren

In this clip he quotes Warren as being a "capitalist in her bones." Bernie thinks that capitalism is part of the problem and that we need a total transformation of the system away from capitalism. Warren instead wants to work within that system. It's really a difference between transformation and reform. The capitalistic system at this point is so grievously unequal and unfair that we really need to go beyond it. Sanders takes steps in the direction. Warren, while her reforms are good, doesn't go all the way to the root of capitalism itself.

Reich: 5 ways to reform the Supreme Corp

Given how it has become a completely partisan organ of the Repugnantan Party, how do we reform it? Reich offers 5 ways, bullet points below. Watch the video for the details.

1. Impose term limits.
2. Reinforce ethics standards.
3. Disclose finances online.
4. Add more seats.
5. Rotating panel.

Compare and contrast who gets what welfare

There really is no comparison.


The collective computation of reality in nature and society

At the Santa Fe Institute. As always, after the presentation it will be available at their YouTube page (also live streaming). Another example of how semi-autonomous parts operate interdependently and synchronously with others in relation.

"The first computers were not invented by humans but by nature. The mantra of complexity science—that complexity arises from interactions among simple components—is wrong. The parts—whether cells, neurons, bees, or humans—are often wonderfully complex themselves but operate under many constraints and are prone to failure and myopia and, consequently, errors in information processing that can lead to a profound misunderstanding of the nature of reality. In this public lecture, Jessica Flack will discuss how nature computes. She will build on the above points to argue collective computation—computation by the parts together—evolved as a solution to imperfect information processing, sometimes resulting in recovery of the 'ground truth out there in the world' and sometimes resulting in a collectively constructed reality that takes on a life and meaning of its own. Flack will also discuss how an understanding of computation in nature challenges us to broaden our understanding of computation’s theoretical foundations."

Interpersonal synchrony feels good but impedes self-regulation of affect

The abstract of the above article:

"The social benefits of interpersonal synchrony are widely recognized. Yet, little is known about its impact on the self. According to enactive cognitive science, the human self for its stability and regulation needs to balance social attunement with disengagement from others. Too much interpersonal synchrony is considered detrimental for a person’s ability to self-regulate. In this study, 66 adults took part in the Body-Conversation Task (BCT), a dyadic movement task promoting spontaneous social interaction. Using whole-body behavioural imaging, we investigated the simultaneous impact of interpersonal synchrony (between persons) and intrapersonal synchrony (within a person) on positive affect and self-regulation of affect. We hypothesized that interpersonal synchrony’s known tendency to increase positive affect would have a trade-off, decreasing a person’s ability to self-regulate affect. Interpersonal synchrony predicted an increase in positive affect. Consistent with our hypothesis, it simultaneously predicted a weakening in self-regulation of affect. Intrapersonal synchrony, however, tended to oppose these effects. Our findings challenge the widespread belief that harmony with others has only beneficial effects, pointing to the need to better understand the impact of interaction dynamics on the stability and regulation of the human self."

The conclusion:

Monday, October 14, 2019