Tuesday, June 5, 2018

Shep Smith on Dump's self pardon

What did Dump say when he colluded with Russia? Pardon me. Smith of Pox discusses it in this video (starting around 0:50), correcting the Presidunce that he does not have that power and provides evidence from the Constitution.

The excluded and included middle

From the archive.

In this post I discussed Graham Priest's article on Buddhist logic, which argues around Aristotle's excluded middle. The latter is prerequisite to the claim of performative contradiction, whereas Priest's Buddhist logic doesn't accept that premise. Priest's logic is what he calls paraconsistent, and I of course twist and fold it even further to show how their is an ultimate truth, but not in the metaphysical sense.

Accepting the excluded middle is a hallmark of formal operations with its bivalent either/or, and in that sense is 'metaphysical.' Postformal dialectics of the kind Priest discusses goes 'postmetaphysical' in that sense, while still making metaphysical (ontological) claims as to the nature of reality. I've also weaved this into Lakoff's work on embodied realism in various threads (especially real/false reason), another story, but 'on topic' to this thread.

You'll have to read the linked Priest article on Buddhist logic. It's only a contradiction to formal logic that accepts the excluded middle. Recall in Wilber's intro to the fourth turning the 4-fold Buddhist logic: something is, is not, is both, is neither. And used it to justify nonconceptual direct experience as the answer. Priest does a far better job on explaining this. Interestingly, and more than just a pun, it's no accident that Madhyamaka is called the 'middle' way.* It's between conceptual and nonconceptual, absolute and relative etc. in how it mediates these same/differences. Like Desilet and Derrida, not coincidentally.

Monday, June 4, 2018

A relational and renewal perspective

Continuing this post, from Integral Renewal: A Relational and Renewal Perspective by Lassem and Schieffer, Routledge, 2016, p. 391:

"Instead then of seeing the world in terms of conceptual categories of a logic of contradiction [...] we view it in terms of a logic of dialectic, in which opposites interpenetrate. We become aware of the interfusion of dynamic events in mutual exchange, the interpenetration of cause and effect."

Supreme Corp rules in wedding cake case

Apparently the ruling did not decide the larger issues in the case, instead ruling that just for this specific case that the Colorado Civil Rights Commission and the Appeals Court demonstrated a hostility to religion so vacated their decisions. According to Kagan's concurring opinion: "The Court limits its analysis to the reasoning of the state agencies (and Court of Appeals)" (3).

More Dimocrapic Party corruption

Glenn Greenwald on the corrupt re-nomination of Bob Menendez in the Senate. And while blocking good primary challengers. The Party needs to be overtaken by progressives and they're working on it, but the corruption is so entrenched that it's a long, long war.

"Here's your Democratic Party, the reason they have collapsed as a national political force: they united behind one of the sleaziest and most corrupt incumbent Senators in the country, preventing credible primary challengers and - even after he barely escaped federal conviction on bribery charges (brought by the Obama DOJ), had his legal defense fund supported by Sheldon Adelson, the Kushners, and AIPAC officials, and just got 'severely admonished' by the Senate Ethics Committee - they are ensuring that New Jersey Democrats on Tuesday have no choice but to send him back to the Senate for yet another term. You can't beat Trump and the GOP without fixing the severe sicknesses within the Democratic Party, exemplified by Bob Menendez."

Charity and Andres on World of Dance

Sneak peek of the upcoming episode.

The Warriors win game 2

There are just too good of a team for the Cavs, with so many weapons. The Cavs may have the best player in James, but he gets little, ineffective support from an inferior team. I wonder if the Cavs will win any games in this series? You can skip the first 15 seconds of this video, an ad.

Good critique of 'integral'

Joseph Dillard's FB post copied below.

"As a long-term progressive and supporter of Integral, my frustration, irritation, and anger with Integral, SD, "New Age," and all things progressive, is that while they are obsessed with Trump, culture wars, and social justice warriors who bizarrely attack the likes of Jordan Peterson, they are generally curiously silent about issues of justice and obedience to international law, particularly where Israel is concerned, but also in blaming Russia for our own collective deceit, corruption, and imperialism. I include Steven Pinker, who I greatly admire, in that critique. Is this a manifestation of a fear of being labeled "anti-Semitic?" Of appearing "un-PC?" Does being "fair and balanced" mean changing the subject from our responsibility to that of others? Is it the manifestation of a genuine belief that an uplifting of consciousness will save the day, when the data shows it has been the spread of universal standards of lawful behavior that has reduced violence world-wide and raised measures of well-being, not professions of religions, or of morality, and spirituality? Is it a sort of elitist, exceptionalistic arrogance that says that we and ours must be more evolved, more spiritual, even if we and our allies are killing people in cold blood? Is there really a meme or level of development that is higher or more sacred than reciprocity in respect for human rights? Can we realistically claim that our priority is compassion toward all sentient beings if we are not ready to defend for others those rights that we demand for ourselves? So we celebrate our mutual Teal wonderfulness in Hungary at the European Integral Conference while essentially ignoring issues of international justice and law? Just what level of development is that?"

Boundaries, hierarchies and networks in complex systems

Paper by Cilliars. Some excerpts:

"In the first place it must be underscored that systems cannot do without hierarchies. [...] Problems arise, however, when these hierarchies are seen as either too clearly defined, or too permanent. The classical understanding of hierarchies tends to view them as being nested. In reality however, hierarchies are not that well-structured. They interpenetrate each other, i.e. there are relationships which cut across different hierarchies. These interpenetrations may be fairly limited, or so extensive that it becomes difficult to typify the hierarchy accurately in terms of prime and subordinate parts" (7).

Sunday, June 3, 2018

The Adventures of Ed the Head, Chapter Three

It's still in this document, starting at the bottom of page 15. No more teasers, just go read it.