I appreciate Stein's ITC '15 paper. Metrics and measurements impact
us all in every aspect of our lives, not just externally but in the very
way we think and behave. Hence we need better metrics to ensure better
lives, since modernistic late capitalism has come up not only lacking
but quite detrimental.
And of course Stein
recommends an integral-based measurement system that requires the new
sciences of chaos, complexity and emergence. The old paradigm of "heroic
modernity" is limited to linear, isolated, singular phenomenon taken
out of its context and environment. But dynamic systems require
"multitudinous measures across multiple time scales" (39). The
latter metrics can facilitate "the emergence of a post-capitalist
socio-sphere" (41) which goes beyond measuring worth in just monetary
terms but includes volunteer work, environmental stewardship, good
citizenship and social justice activism.
Since
measurement systems have such a deep impact in all aspects of our lives,
it must include those most affected in that process, i.e. they must
have democratic input in the very creation of such metrics. This
challenges the modernist conception of expertise as the only arbiter of
measurement. The experts are still needed for their part, but the rest
of us are needed to define the parameters of its use, as well as examine
the ethical and policy implications, or merely to provide feedback which
must recycle into the measurements.
And here we
circle around once again to collaborative enactment, which indeed is the
next wave of humanity already arising in our midst. We can have
societal impact by doing our parts in enacting such new measures for the
kind of world we want, be it in creating the scientific measures,
critically examining them for post-conventional (and postmetaphysical)
ethical standards, how they would affect political policies and how that
affects the lives of the rest of us. Meanwhile the rest of us are
valued for our feedback on how exactly our lives are indeed affected,
and is taken into consideration from the other cohorts working to
create such metrics.
This is indeed the dawning of the age of the collaborative commons so let's get with the (meta)program people if we truly want to impact our world.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.