In the FB IPS forum Fractal Organism started a thread on the epistemic fallacy. I responded to his statement that "the world we create is necessarily a world of propaganda, and by extension a world of delusions and illusions" with the following:
"I
disagree that propaganda by extension is delusion and illusion. See my
most recent post in the Lakoff thread on the movie Mockingjay. Like
in the movie [...] propaganda requires an emotional connection to
motivate and inspire people to action, like framing per Lakoff. It isn't
necessarily about creating an illusion but about creating embodied and
emotional connection with ideas.
FO: "ok, agreed, but making something embodied and emotional doesnt necessarily take the illusion out, it just gives it tangibility."
Me:
"Of
course, regressives lie, cheat and steal to manipulate their base via
the sort of embodied, emotional propaganda that creates the illusion
that everyone has a fair shot while creating policy that is anything
but. Progressive propaganda dispels that
illusion and tries to create the reality of equal opportunity (not
result) by motivating people to vote for, not against, their own best
interests.
"The
latter is where integral activists might focus their efforts more
productively to enact social transformation by engaging in effective,
progressive and inflaming framing best exemplified by Obama, Sanders and
Warren. As I said in the IPS Mockingjay thread, this is war, at this
point a war of words and frames that shape policy. If done well it could
avert a war of bloody revolution.
And that ain't no epistemic fallacy!"
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.